k were about 100 times as stupid. This year, many teams who saw how detrimental the Forsberg trade was to the Predators (and how beneficial it was to the Flyers) and were more careful. The Red Wings were among these. Big names like Marian Hossa were thrown around, but the Wings never realistically had the pieces to go after Hossa without breaking up the team that had the best record in the NHL. After having 37 defensemen befallen to injury, the Wings went out and got a very reputable defenseman for not a lot, a move applauded by hockey experts. Inevitably, local sports columnist writes column immediately questioning why the Wings didn't do more. Funny thing is, this columnist did the same thing at the baseball trading deadline last year. (And for the record, the Red Sox won the World Series despite Eric Gagne, not because of him.) It's as if there's a canned column waiting on trade deadline day saying "Home team obviously doesn't do enough." The fan reaction on the radio is even funnier. Somehow, tons of fans have inside access that lead them to know abo
ut possible trades that the GM either doesn't know about, or apparently isn't smart enough to take. Then the annual hating on the GM starts. And the panic as they analyze the moves made by other contenders. It all makes for quite good theater. Unfortunately, trade deadline moves haven't proven to be all that successful. In an article last year, a Baseball America writer ranked some of the most notable moves, most turning out to be horrible moves. Jeff Bagwell and John Smoltz, both part of trades late in the season before they became stars. Imagine what Bagwell would have done for the Red Sox or Smoltz for the Tigers (I cry about this one late at night, luckily Doyle Alexander basically was the whole reason the Tigers won the AL East in 1987.) In Detroit, we were on the end of one of the most successful deadline deals, as Rasheed Wallace put the Pistons over the hump on their way to an NBA championship. And the 1994 Rangers were in a similar position as the Wings when they shook up their roster, adding Stephane Matteau among others. But for the most part, trades made at the deadline haven't made that big of a difference. More often, it's been the small move that addressed a weakness without breaking up what was working well to put a team in contention in the first place. But inevitably, the proliferation of moves at the deadline has created millions of would-be GMs who just can't figure out why their favorite team won't make that obvious move to trade Uwe Blab, Tom Beer, Curtis Pride and three second round picks for Michael Jordan, Alex Rodriguez and Mother Teresa. So for all you GMs out there, here's a simple diagram you can put up in your office to remind you what to do on trade deadline day. Do it for the sake of humankind.
